Think hand tools are relics? Think again. In my 20+ years shaping furniture and teaching workshops, the humble tenon saw remains irreplaceable for precision. Forget buzzing routers and screaming table saws – sometimes the quietest tool delivers the purest control. When clean, crisp joinery demands perfection, I consistently reach for my Spear & Jackson B9812 12-inch X 15pts Tenon Saw. Why does this specific tool outshine a drawer full of other back saws? Let’s get hands-on.
Precision Personified: Cutting Through the Specifications
This isn’t just a saw; it’s meticulously engineered for workhorse reliability:
| Feature | Spear & Jackson B9812 | Why It Matters |
|---|---|---|
| Blade Length | 12 inches (305 mm) | Ideal balance: offers control for smaller joints & reach for moderate tenons |
| Teeth Per Inch (TPI) | 15 Points Per Inch (PPI) | Ultra-fine teeth leave a remarkably smooth finish, drastically reducing cleanup time |
| Teeth Configuration | Crosscut | Optimized for slicing across wood grain for clean, tear-out free shoulders and cheeks |
| Blade Material | Hardened & Tempered High-Carbon Steel | Stays sharp significantly longer than softer alternatives, handles demanding hardwoods |
| Back & Spine | Stiff Brass Back | Ensures unwavering blade stability for dead-straight cuts; the backbone of accuracy |
| Handle Material | Traditional Beech | Proven, comfortable feel that molds beautifully to your hand over time |
Bench Tested: B9812 vs. The Competition (Real Workshop Results)
Theory’s great; results matter. I compared the B9812 against two popular contenders in my own shop during a recent walnut tenon project:
-
Contender A: Premium Brand Saw ($$$)
- Cut Quality: Exceptionally smooth (slightly better initial polish).
- Durability: Excellent.
- Control & Feel: Superb balance.
- Drawback: The price tag stung. Did that minor finishing polish justify a 300% cost difference for typical furniture work? Not in my ledger.
-
Contender B: Mid-Range Hardware Store Saw ($)
- Cut Quality: Acceptable but rougher. Required significantly more cleanup/filing.
- Durability: Blade dulled noticeably faster on the dense walnut.
- Control & Feel: Flexed slightly during heavier cuts.
- Drawback: The false economy of a cheap blade became painfully evident through wasted sanding time and premature sharpening needs.
-
Spear & Jackson B9812 ($$):
- Cut Quality: Impressively smooth; cleanup minimal (95%+ as good as Contender A). Leaves a surface ready for glue.
- Durability: Tackled 25+ walnut tenons with minimal sign of dulling. Holds an edge like a true professional tool.
- Control & Feel: Instant confidence. The brass back ensured unwavering straight lines, and the handle proved supremely comfortable over hours.
- The Takeaway: This tool hits the elusive sweet spot – professional performance without the prohibitive professional price.
Where the Spear & Jackson B9812 Shines: Your Project Match
This isn’t a framing saw. Its brilliance emerges in scenarios demanding finesse:
- Hand-cut Joinery: Tailor-made for tenons (shoulders and cheeks), dovetails, half-laps, and precise miters. Its stiffness and fine teeth make joint fitting a pleasure.
- Fine Furniture & Cabinet Making: Cutting delicate moldings, trimming dowels flush, or fitting components where CNC or power tools are too cumbersome or risky.
- Model Making & Small Craft: Provides unmatched control for delicate work in thin stock (use careful support!).
- Restoration & Repair: The gentle control and fine finish are perfect for fixing delicate antiques without splintering old, valuable wood.
Talking Honestly: Potential Speed Bumps & How to Cruise Past Them
This saw prioritizes control and finish over raw speed.
-
Potential Limitation #1: Deliberate Cutting Pace
The ultra-fine 15 PPI teeth cut more slowly in thicker hardwoods (e.g., dense maple, white oak) than an aggressive saw.
My Pro Solution: This is by design! Embrace the precision. Focus on technique: use full, controlled strokes. For thick material, first rough-cut near your line with a coarse saw, then let the B9812 clean up precisely. Sharpness is paramount – hone regularly (a simple saw file does wonders). Rushing ruins the beautiful finish this tool provides. -
Potential Limitation #2: Initial Handle Feel for Some
If you're used only to plastic handles, the solid beech might feel slightly different initially.
My Pro Solution: Give it a week of use. The organic warmth and developing grip of quality beech become uniquely satisfying. Lightly sanding any very minor molding seam (rare) takes seconds.
The Veteran Woodworker's Verdict
The Spear & Jackson B9812 consistently earns its place in my tool chest through intelligent engineering, dependable performance, and outstanding value. It offers the control and fine finish demanded by discerning woodworkers tackling joinery, fine furniture, and detailed projects. While not the fastest saw through thick hardwoods, its focus on precision and an exceptional price-to-performance ratio makes it, hands-down, one of the most reliable and rewarding investments for those who value craftsmanship.